Shortly after we adopted NASA, he started busting outdoors seven times an hour, and we finally gave in. Feathers decided if NASA was going out, she was, too, thank-you-very-much. And then Grey Kitty appeared. I had the vague sense he lived somewhere to the south of us, but I didn't know for sure. He would come round, particularly in the night.
By come round, I mean, he would spot Feathers sitting at 2 am in the window sill 12 inches above my sleeping head, and climb our porch furniture to try and get at her. She would attempt to defend her territory from inside the window, and enormous chaos and noise would ensue. I would be dashing out of bed and chasing him off.
When he caught NASA by our front steps daily, they would more or less try to murder each other. One time, NASA wound up with a badly infected wound from a tail bite after one of these skuffles, which involved a spendy trip to the emergency vet. It also propelled Anne away from sleeping in her top bunk and back into my bed for a year.
Another time, he was jumping at Feathers in the wee hours while she was sitting in the window over my desk. He managed to slash the screen open and Feathers fell out the window. So there I was running outside at dark o'clock to collect her and bring her back in.
I said once to Jared that I have never disliked any cat, but I hated Grey Kitty. Any time I saw him near our property, I chased him off. He was super inconvenient and expensive, and I was annoyed at his anonymous owners for letting him run around all night and be so difficult and expensive.
Black Bean was pretty good at putting him in his place. All Beaner had to do if Grey Kitty came in the back yard on his watch was to sit up tall and make the merest, faintest hissing noise, and Grey Kitty would tuck tail and run.
One evening this June we were eating dinner on our back patio, when we heard the traditional sounds of Grey Kitty beating up on NASA. So to war whoops of "Cat fight! Cat fight!" I went running through the gate to chase off the scoundrel. Our neighbor across the street and one over was out and asked about the commotion. She had many stories to tell, including the sad tale that her husband had passed away and she would be moving out of state. I learned from her that Grey Kitty was a stray, and she had been feeding him. (No wonder he had been hanging around!) And that he was really sweet and loved to be petted. And that when she left, she was thinking of trying to get him to a shelter so he could be adopted into a good home.
At the end of July, said neighbor took off for Illinois after a lot of selling, packing, and dumpster throwing; a crew of workmen showed up and began the remodeling process. And Grey Kitty continued showing up for show downs with NASA. We realized she hadn't found a home for him, and feeling sorry for his poor, hungry tummy and scrappy life, we started feeding him. We fed him at night, after our cats were safely in, right out by the sidewalk, as far from the house as possible. He started showing up on cue, though keeping out of sight.
As we felt more and more responsible toward him, we had our cat sitter feed him while we were camping on the Penninsula. Then, we started moving his feeding location closer and closer to the house. He started turning up at other times of day and flopping down to get petted. As the neighbor had said, he was really sweet (when he wasn't beating up NASA.) With closer contact it became clear he was not fixed, and he had lots of small scars and scratches on his head from fighting. He was hypervigilant when we fed him, and he was hypervigilant about anyone walking down the street, even when their path was parallel rather than intersecting and they were many yards away. He was clearly acquainted with the neighborhood 'Possum and gave 'Possum his passing rights. Everything about him screamed 'stray who had made his own way for a long time', though I estimates he was young-ish - under five years.
We all, especially the kids, started getting rather attached to him, and decided we had better just adopt him. I called the vet and scheduled an appointment for him few Fridays out. I would have the day off from work and could do what it took to capture him. Once we got his food dish to the front porch, we brought out our largest cat carrier and started feeding him in there. And then we would close the door for a short time. I started picking him up briefly. The next step was to move the carrier with him in it. We were helping him acclimate to his new home, and he made a couple of brief, supervised forays into the house when the other cats were out back. We started heading off fights before they happened and worked to keep all the animals calm.
Sunday at noon, Grey Kitty had come around, so I had fed him, and I was on the front porch socializing with him (he was so sweet and cuddly!), when a budget car (that's mostly the kind we see on our street) rolled up, stopped in the middle of the street, and disgorged a pajama-clad young woman. She called to me: "Have you seen a grey cat?" I pointed to Grey Kitty and replied, "This one?" assuming that it must be some other grey cat she was after. She walked up to the porch, took a look at Grey Kitty, cried out "Charlie!" and scooped him up in her arms!
It turned out she was the teenage daughter of a man three houses south of us (who was the owner of two dangerous and unruly dogs. He did not maintain his fence and repaired it with random pieces of broken plastic stuff. The dogs were in the habit of chasing anyone who walked down the alley, so in the last many months we have avoided that part of the street. They have terrified grown men who have come yelling down the alley with their aggressive behavior. Long ago, another alley neighbor had tried to speak with this man about his dogs and and was told she was the one disturbing his dogs' training. We were concerned about the situation here and had discussed who at the city to contact about the dogs and fence issue.) The cat, Charlie, was hers, and she had gotten him three years ago before her mother died. She had graduated from high-school this June and moved up north to start her adult life. Her father and the younger three kids living in the house (and the dogs) had just moved to Bothell and left her cat behind. Because of those dogs, the family never closed the back door of the house, so Charlie was free time come and go at all hours. I'm sure the girl had no idea what all her cat was up to in the middle of the night, and really didn't know he'd be better off neutered and with vaccines...
Anyway, she thanked us for taking care of him, I called the kids out of the house for an unexpected and precipitous goodbye, the girl walked back to her car with Charlie snuggled in her embrace, and Grey Kitty disappeared from our lives forever. I was stunned, and I have taken it hardest of anyone in our family. Worst enemies can easily become best friends, and it doesn't help that Jared pointed out that Grey Kitty would probably have had a nicer life if he's stayed with us.