Now that my eldest is attending public school, I keep digging through my own school experience to compare. I have many distinct memories of fourth grade, so I will start there. I think I will leave Anne's fourth grade experience out of it, because that is her own story.
My class at our neighborhood elementary school met in the right half of a portable we shared with a fifth grade. The portable across from us had a sixth grade class, as well as a mixed 5th/6th class. Around the corner, closer to the main building was the portable with Miss Jeffrey (music) on the left and the frightening-to-me Mrs. Mendoza (art) on the right. Around the next corner was the portable with the other two fourth grade teachers.
I liked Miss Jeffrey and her class. She was young, and probably had a general education music degree. I was far younger, of course, and obsessed with Baroque and even older music, studying - with the required daily nagging and imprecations from my parent - the violin and piano at an intermediate level (easy Mozart sonatas, and Vivaldi concertos, for example), sang in church choirs, and as my mother put it, "played anything that wasn't nailed down." I was always divising instrumental teaching curricula for fun and was about to launch my own now-forgotten, private classical composing career. Miss Jeffrey's class was easy, and interesting, and I eagerly joined the team for something called "Music Memory" - a statewide contest where we had a list of art pieces to memorize from genre ranging from Baroque to 20th century with some ragtime thrown in. At the actual contest, all of the teams crowded into UT's Bass Concert Hall and listened to the Austin Civic Orchestra (with whom I would solo a few times in the upcoming years) play little excerpts, drop-the-needle style from the list, while we were to annotate the blank page in front of us with the title and composer of each work. I also distinctly remember seeing and hearing Westside Story on film for the first time, thanks to Miss Jeffrey. Once I was quite embarrassed for being singled out when she was teaching us something and couldn't recall a specific musical term at the moment; I raised my hand and supplied the missing term, and she kindly and jokingly said she should hand me her masters degree off the wall. We studied the recorder in her class, and I took this endeavor seriously, eventually amassing not just the required soprano, but also an alto and tenor. When I had some spending money, I would go to the sheet music store and purchase volumes of recorder music to read through, and I also taped a Handel recorder sonata off the classical station and carefully and diligently learned it by ear. Miss Jeffrey formed an after-school recorder club, which I immediately joined, and we prepared music to take on tour to the little Renaissance Festival one weekend in Waxahachie, a small town between Dallas and Waco. My mother made me a costume from a Breugel painting, and it is possible that our Saturday journey to that magical place of imagined historical reenactment was one of the highest highlights of my first decade. Miss Jeffrey also had an after school choir club, which I joined, and a young astronauts club, which was another area of great interest to me. I very much looked forward to sixth grade when I could join the orchestra and learn the cello. However, I did not remain in that school long enough to see that dream come to fruition.
Mrs. Mendoza, the art teacher, seemed pretty hands off. I said she frightened me, which was true, but I am not sure why. Perhaps I was not able to read her well enough to predict if I was pleasing her or not. She would present the project we were doing - making a collage of our family from old magazines, or using clay to make candle holders, or whatever. Then she would circulate around the room to check up on our work, and I mostly didn't want her to come round to me and tell me I was doing it wrong. I still have the afore-mentioned candle holder and a clay baby guinea pig I lovingly made in her class. I always loved making art, but mostly for my own enjoyment and edification, and not so much in this uncomfortable setting.
My own homeroom teacher was the very young Mrs. Baker, who left us for many weeks in the spring when she gave birth to her first child. One afternoon not long before the school's-out bell rang, Mrs. Baker called to all of us in an atypically sappy voice with unusual-for-her word choice: "Gather round, children. " I had no idea why she was talking out of character and immediately felt embarrassed and confused. I "gathered round" as requested, with my back very intentionally toward her so that I would not have to deal with the intensity of seeing her face or anyone else seeing mine, as I processed this weird off-the-script encounter. She announced to us, that as many of the class had observed (though not I), she was pregnant and would be leaving us soon for some weeks when her baby was born. I felt excited about the idea of the baby, as I think I have always been drawn to the tiniest humans, but I also felt betrayed. It takes so long to get used to a new teacher and new routine, and now I would have to do it again with a stranger. (We ended up with a man in his 50s who probably carried on as best he could with us, but I was relieved when Mrs. Baker returned.)
Each day I, and a few others, went to Mrs. Ramirez's class for language arts, as this was a subject we switched classes for. Mrs. Ramirez was probably in her 50s or 60s, and lived in the neighborhood; sometimes I would see her walking home from school. She was regarded by the kids as the toughest 4th grade teacher, and I liked her, while I also felt little personal connection with her. In retrospect, it was probably the most advanced readers who were sent to her for language arts, and she stretched and challenged us. My usual odd written drivel, inspired by language of previous decades and centuries with which I had rather insufficient experience, didn't merit automatic adulation from her. At one point we were to give a report on a topic she helped us choose, complete with hand-drawn slides. Naturally I wanted to do something about music, and was rather frustrated when she assigned me, to broaden my horizons, the topic of jazz, a style which was distinctly uninteresting to me for its lack of antiquity and foreign-ness. We also did a poetry project and I still have the mimeographed book of 4th grade poems and illustrations we put together. I still rather like one of my illustrations of my brother in the middle of his technology projects, but my own poetic contributions were rather insipid.
After lunch we went to Mrs. Thomson, the final (middle-aged) 4th grade teacher, who was notable in our mostly-white neighborhood as being the only African-American faculty member. It was for health class one semester and D.A.R.E. (to keep kids off drugs) the other semester. D.A.R.E .was slightly more interesting than health, as we got to hear all about the gruesome results of substance abuse. Health was more mundane, and probably more useful, as we read in our incredibly dull text book about the importance of hand washing, the four food groups, and wearing helmets and giving hand signals when riding our bikes.
Mrs. Baker's class was comfortable enough. Two academic points stand out to me. We had our daily math book, which was full of the regular arithmetic numbers manipulation, which I rather liked. Then there was a secondary math book which I liked rather less, called Real Math Book, which was filled with word problems. When assigning classwork or homework from said volume, she would write on the board: R.M.B. p. 17 #3,4,6,8,15. As you can see, those are my initials, too, and I always felt that those assignments were directed at me.
The second notable item was that when we opened our social studies book for the year (it was a Texas-based book), there was a demonstration map showing how to read a map key. The map was of a real place, as it was paired with an aerial photo. I caught its import immediately. It was the city park on the same property as our school and was the playground on which we took our daily recess, fifty feet from where we were now seated. I felt some pride of place, knowing that students all over the state would be studying OUR park.
Each morning after we were arrived and settled and announcements had been made, our first activity was to walk as a class to "specials." The music and art were already alluded to. The third on the daily rotation, was P.E. The P.E. teacher I found most terrifying. She was tall and stocky, her wild, long, crimped hair, streaked with early gray stored in an 80's scrunchy, wavy bangs across her forehead. She dressed in matched sweat suits and athletic shoes, and wore oversize, loud, dangly earrings. She never spoke, she always shouted; she never encouraged, she always cheered; her whistle was shrill, and she kept us in order. I was happiest when I was at the back of the gym, as far from her as I could muster, but we had assigned and rotating spots on the floor for our daily warm-ups, so proximity was not to be helped on a schedule. I rarely earned an A in her class: I was small, slow, awkward, uncoordinated, short on stamina, and very disconnected from the rules of organized sports. We did a unit on football (a subject which I have never learned to appreciate in the slightest), and on the written test, which I failed miserably, we had the chance to earn extra credit by writing in the names of professional players. I remember one boy laughing and remarking that that was the stupidest, easiest extra credit ever, and I cringed inside, as I would have no way of picking such a name out of the thin air. (I may do no better today.) I did enjoy track and field day, because I loved running hurdles.
Each day, midday, we took a trip to the industrial-smelling, noisy cafeteria, where Mrs. Baker took leave of us for 20 or 30 minutes. On rare occasions I went through the lunch line and had to endure the terror of talking to the lunch ladies, pointing out which items I wanted on my tray and the terror of trying to pay the correct amount to the cashiers. Usually, though, I had the standard lunch, packed daily by my mother - a sandwich, usually peanut butter and honey or tuna salad (or on rare occasions cheese), along with something plant-y: apple slices, orange sections, or carrot sticks. This, plus an apple juice box. We had assigned seats at our class's two assigned brown fake-wood-topped, folding cafeteria tables, with their alternating attached blue and orange circular seats. There were more girls than boys in the class, and Jennifer and I were assigned seats together at the boys' table. Jennifer was quiet and studious, as I was, but seemingly less awkward. I assume we were assigned to the rowdy boys' table, because Mrs. Baker thought we could be a good influence on them. It may, instead, have cemented our social distance from the more popular girls and made us the target of merciless teasing by the boys. I was gullible and unsure of what was malicious and what was meant in good humor, so I became the brunt of much teasing, moreso, I think, than Jennifer. I dealt with this injustice by raising my hand at each infraction from the boys, who seemed to be eating this up, and reporting each misdemeanor to the lunch monitors. These poor, long-suffering lunch monitors must have quickly reported this continual annoyance to Mrs. Baker, as she soon produced a laminated copy of the lunch seating chart, and a dry-erase marker, which I was to take to lunch each day and mark the infractions on. This had the positive effect of reducing the lunch monitors' constantly and fruitlessly visiting our table, and I think over time it reduced the boys' tormenting of us, allowing Jennifer and me to eat in relative peace, while still desperately longing to join the girls' table, which problem was never resolved. I handed the marked chart and marker back to Mrs. Baker when she came to retrieve us as we lined up to leave for recess. Once I was hurt to see her erasing my list of unassailable accusations without inspecting them. I was, however, inwardly assured that whether or not she cared, I had done my duty in promoting justice. I have puzzled over this lunch situation many times throughout the years and have never really decided what to make of the whole thing, my own part included. I was invited to Jennifer's birthday party, where I saw an Ouiji board for the first and only time.
I went to a few other birthday parties that year, too, including those of the other girls in my "club". Margie, whom I had known since preschool, had asked me to join a little club she started, whose membership included two others besides us - one, her future stepsister, though it would be a few years before they knew about that, and another girl who lived up the hill, daughter of a pastor father and Amway sales woman, who had a fabulous trampoline. The club did not have much of a point or any bylaws, but by jove, we were a club, and got our parents to approve meetups at the various houses every couple of weeks, though mostly not mine.
There was one other whose birthday party I remember with much vividness. The celebrant was Stephanie Villegas, and she lived across the street from my former piano teacher, and more exotically, a few doors down from her own older cousin. Hers was a sleepover party, which I was permitted to stay for all of, and the centerpiece of this gathering was the watching of the newly released New Kids on the Block video. As a rule, I was against pop music, on account of its lack of antiquity and its obvious vapidity, but this boy band was all the rage amongst the female turning-ten set. I don't entirely know the reasons - were the ripped jeans and dance moves considered hot? Were they all looking forward to the freewheeling world of junior high and (ew!) dating in a few years like their older sisters? I mostly did not watch the video, carefully keeping my back to it most of the time, but my musical mind couldn't help but get sucked into notating and secretly enjoying the repetitious refrains....
...We hung our backpacks in the cupboard in the back of Mrs. Baker's classroom, and once I chanced to have left a cloth bound blank book in my bag, which I brought from home. I learned from one of my neighbor boys that he and a couple others were in the habit of snooping through everyone's things, as he told me they'd found this book. And was it my diary? And they hadn't read it, because it was probably full of gross stuff. I was careful to excise with scissors everything that could be construed as gross stuff that evening in sheer horror (don't recall now what that might be), and I still have that book with many years of pictures and words, with probably a quarter of the pages removed by me.
During recess I mostly kept to myself, but interacted with others when our paths crossed. We had a fun playground and some magical, gnarled live oaks.
I did talk with a boy called Richard who sat at my table for math. I think he was in one of the other fourth grades and came to Mrs. Baker's class for math. He was funny without making fun of me, and I enjoyed his company.
There was another boy who came for math who was often sent to the principal's office on account of being disruptive. I marveled at his lawlessness as he related a story, which I believe to be true, of being dropped off at school in the morning, sneaking out the back and hanging out at home while his dad was at work, wandering over to play pinball at 7-11, and returning to school in time for pick up without being caught. He was disruptive enough they sent him to Dill for a couple of weeks, which I learned later was the district's reform school for their toughest behavioral cases. From the distance of more than 30 years, I wonder whether visits to the office and Dill made positive or negative impact or any impact at all, what was making school hard for that boy, and what ever became of him in later years.
One more thing sticks out to me from fourth grade. In usual fashion, I had created something I had rather enjoyed in my free time at home. This one was a detailed map, in colored pencil, of a mythical land, drawn from various literary and artistic resources in my mind. I was quite pleased that I had seen this vision to fruition and not dropped it for another grand idea partway through, which was a common enough occurrence. I wanted to show it to Mrs. Baker, and I was much too shy to just go talk to her about it - there was no script for such a scenario, and I would have been too nervous to make more than a squeak, anyway. So I put it in the homework basket with a note, saying I was submitting it for extra credit. I was rather fond of the map and looked forward to having it handed back in a day or two. When it was not returned promptly, I panicked, but waited another day. I submitted another note to the homework basket requesting its return, and Mrs. Baker caught me at a quick moment before recess to let me know she thought it was brilliant and had not returned it yet, because she wanted to show it to other teachers. My response was a squeaked OK, but inwardly I felt humiliated. I did not want to be some object the teachers were discussing behind my back (even for supposed brilliance); I had only wanted, in my own awkward indirect way, to make a connection with an adult over a topic that I found exciting.
During the summer break, I was at the mall with my mother (a chore I am not sure either of us liked) when we ran into Mrs. Baker with her baby boy in a stroller. I did not recognize her, as she was in the wrong place, and I was not in the habit of recognizing adults' faces anyway. She and my mother chatted, and I was probably remonstrated to give a hello. She seemed a stranger to me, off somewhere in the giant universe full of social rules made up by adults, that I couldn't ever quite grasp sufficiently.